Skip to main content

Why Shouting Doesn’t Work (and What I Do Instead)

If you’ve ever raised your voice in class, you’re not alone. Every teacher gets pushed to that point at some stage. But over time, I realised something uncomfortable: shouting might stop the noise for a moment, but it doesn’t actually fix the problem.

It just creates a different one.

What Really Happens When We Shout

At first, shouting seems effective. The class goes quiet. Students look up. You feel like you’ve regained control.

But look a little closer:

  • Students go quiet out of fear, not understanding

  • The same behaviour comes back again

  • Some students switch off completely

  • Your relationship with the class takes a hit

Instead of building respect, shouting often builds tension. And once that becomes your main tool, students start to depend on it. They only listen when the volume goes up.

It Drains You Too

Shouting isn’t just hard on students, it’s exhausting for you.

You end up:

  • Losing your voice

  • Feeling frustrated more often

  • Starting lessons already on edge

That kind of energy carries into everything you do. Teaching becomes more about control than learning.

What I Do Instead

It didn’t change overnight, but I started replacing shouting with a few simple strategies that actually work long term.

1. Lower My Voice Instead of Raising It

This feels backwards, but it works.

When the class gets noisy, I pause and speak more softly. Students naturally lean in or quiet down to hear. It shifts attention without creating fear.

2. Use Silence as a Tool

Instead of talking over the noise, I stop.

I stand still and wait. At first, it feels uncomfortable. But slowly, students notice. A few go quiet, then others follow. It builds a habit where they recognise that silence means something.

3. Set Clear Routines

Most noise comes from uncertainty.

So I make instructions simple and consistent:

  • What to do

  • How to do it

  • How long they have

When students know exactly what’s expected, there’s less chance for things to get out of control.

4. Acknowledge the Students Doing the Right Thing

Instead of focusing on the noise, I highlight the behaviour I want.

“I like how this group is ready.”
“I can see some students already started.”

It shifts attention without calling anyone out directly, and others quickly follow.

5. Move Around the Classroom

Proximity is powerful.

Standing near a noisy group often quiets them without saying a word. It keeps things calm and avoids turning small issues into big ones.

The Real Difference

The biggest change wasn’t just in behaviour, it was in the classroom atmosphere.

Students became:

  • More relaxed

  • More responsive

  • More willing to participate

And I felt more in control without constantly raising my voice.

Final Thought

Shouting might give quick results, but it doesn’t build the kind of classroom you actually want. Calm, consistent strategies take a bit more patience at the start, but they last.

And in the long run, you don’t just manage behaviour better, you build respect that doesn’t depend on volume.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Enhancing Education Through ClassDojo, Seesaw, and Google Classroom.

  Class Dojo What makes an interesting classroom?  Is it the teacher? Or that nice view of the school playground so that you can sit in class and daydream about playing with friends during recess and lunch? I think it's something you can not see. Because an interesting classroom is defined as the classroom community that's built between teachers, students, and parents. This is because a classroom where students work together, persevere through obstacles, and help each other along the way makes for a classroom that is headed for success.  Class Dojo allows everyone, specially students, to celebrate  and share those moments in class and at home. Class Dojo grants each student user a monster avatar and every time students display any important skills - for example, helping others, being on task, participating in class, teamwork, etcetera - teachers can award points on Class Dojo. Additionally, videos and photos can be taken and uploaded to the Class Dojo to showcase exc...
2 comments
Read more

Say What to Do, Not What Not to Do: The Power of Positive Instruction

“Don’t run.” “Don’t shout.” “Don’t talk.” We say these all the time. It feels natural. But there’s a problem with this approach. It tells students what not to do, but it doesn’t tell them what they should be doing instead. That small shift in language can make a big difference in your classroom. What’s Missing in “Don’t…” When you say “don’t run,” the instruction stops there. A student might pause, but then what? Should they walk? Should they stand still? Should they line up? The actual expectation is missing. Some students figure it out. Others guess. And some just continue the behaviour because they were never clearly told what to do instead. This is where behaviour issues often repeat. Not because students are being difficult, but because the instruction wasn’t complete. What Positive Instruction Looks Like Positive instruction simply means telling students the behaviour you want to see. Instead of: “Don’t run” → “Walk smartly” “Don’t shout” → “Use a quiet voice” “Don’t push” → “...
Post a Comment
Read more

5 Fun Ways to Teach Place Value to Year 4 Students

Teaching place value to Year 4 can feel repetitive if you stick to just numbers on the board. But once you turn it into something hands-on and interactive, students start to actually get it instead of memorising it. Here are five simple, fun ways that work well in a real classroom. 1. Human Place Value Chart Turn your students into the numbers. Draw columns on the ground or board (Thousands, Hundreds, Tens, Ones). Give students number cards (0–9) and ask them to stand in the correct place to form a number. For example, to make 3,482, four students stand in the correct columns holding 3, 4, 8, and 2. Then mix it up: Swap students and ask, “What number do we have now?” Ask questions like, “Who has the greatest value?” It gets them moving and thinking at the same time. 2. Place Value with Bundles (Sticks or Straws) Make place value visible. Use sticks, straws, or even rolled paper: 10 sticks tied together = 1 ten 10 tens = 1 hundred Give groups a number and ask them to build it. For exam...
Post a Comment
Read more